
Dan Pallotta has been interviewed several times on the airwaves and in print recently with the launch of his new book "Uncharitable." Dan floated a great idea of a charity stock market. What a great idea to be able to invest in companies that excel at charity! One thing is for sure - the government has shown clearly that it is horrible at administering charity (ie the Great Society, the New Deal and so on). That might be in part because government charity is unconstitutional. I was listening to the great economist Walter Williams the other day, and was amazed to find out that the Constitution was never set up to be a charitable organization (as evidenced by the quotes below.) The economist replayed a recent interview with the Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid and the interviewer asked Reid about whether it was appropriate for the government to confiscate money from one individual to give it to the welfare of another. Reid replied when cornered that taxes are voluntary. He wasn't about to admit that yes indeed, he wants a government that requires you to give more for the welfare of another.
Imagine government ceasing all its welfare programs in favor of private for-profit companies in which you can invest. The money you give is tax deductible, and the money you invest brings you a dividend at the same time. The more efficient companies that raise lots of efficient dollars for good causes stay in business. The causes get more money because the free-market system naturally means that the cream rises to the top: Good causes get more money and you get a return on the dollar while getting a good feeling about helping someone.
Bottom line, Dan is right in advocating that we should be welcoming companies who are very good and efficient at raising money for good causes. He says not look at how much of your dollar is directly going to your cause - look at how efficently your dollar is being used for your cause.
The free enterprise system proves that if an individual is given enough incentive to reap the rewards of his or her labor, anything is possible. Dan should know - he's raised $305 million in 9 years for the fight against AIDS and breast cancer.
So as we head into a new government that wants to spread the wealth, remember that is is unconstitutional for a good reason: The framers of the Constitution knew that the people themselves would be better at administering charity. It is not a crime to reap rewards for helping someone else.
"The government of the United States is a definite government, confined to specified objects. It is not like state governments, whose powers are more general. Charity is no part of the legislative duty of the government."
-- James Madison, speech in the House of Representatives, January 10, 1794
"I cannot undertake to lay my finger on that article of the Constitution which granted a right to Congress of expending, on objects of benevolence, the money of their constituents."
-- James Madison, 4 Annals of congress 179 (1794)'
No comments:
Post a Comment